« Free Speech and the Liberal Democrats. | Main | David Brooks: When Big Brother Is You »

December 22, 2005

Bob Herbert: Blowing the Whistle on Gansta Culture.

Sorry, is the earth still turning in its orbit? Bob Herbert’s column today makes him sound like Bill Cosby.

Surely this is a portent of the End Times?


Edwin ''E. J.'' Duncan was a young man from a decent family who spent a great deal of time with his friends in an amateur recording studio his parents had set up for him in the basement of their home in the Dorchester neighborhood.

It was in that studio that Duncan, along with three of his closest friends, was murdered last week, shot to death by a killer or killers who have yet to be found. Whoever carried out the executions, it seems clear enough to me that young Duncan and his friends were among the latest victims of the profoundly self-destructive cultural influences that have spread like a cancer through much of the black community and beyond.

I keep wondering when leaders of eminence will step forward and declare, unambiguously, that enough is enough, as they did in the heyday of the civil rights movement, when the enemy was white racism.

It is time to blow the whistle on the nitwits who have so successfully promoted a values system that embraces murder, drug-dealing, gang membership, misogyny, child abandonment and a sense of self so diseased that it teaches children to view the men in their orbit as niggaz and the women as hoes.

However this madness developed, it's time to bring it to an end.

I noticed that Jesse Jackson, Al Sharpton, Louis Farrakhan, Snoop Dogg and other ''leaders'' and celebrities turned out in South Central Los Angeles on Tuesday for the funeral of Stanley ''Tookie'' Williams, the convicted killer and co-founder of the Crips street gang who was executed in California last week.

I remember talking over the years to parents in Los Angeles and elsewhere who were petrified that their children would be killed in cold blood -- summarily executed, without any possibility of a defense or an appeal -- by the Crips or some other gang because they just happened to be wearing the wrong color cap or jacket or whatever.

The enthusiastic turnout at Tookie Williams's funeral tells you much of what you need to know about the current state of black leadership in the U.S.

The slaughter of E. J. Duncan, who was 21, and his friends -- Jason Bachiller, 21; Jihad Chankhour, 22; and Christopher Vieira, 19 -- was all but literally accompanied by a hip-hop soundtrack. Duncan, Bachiller and Vieira were members of a rap group called Graveside, which favored the rough language and violent imagery that has enthralled so many youngsters and bolstered the bottom lines of major entertainment companies.

This mindless celebration of violence, the essence of gangsta rap, is a reflection of the nihilism that has taken root in one neighborhood after another over the past few decades, destroying many, many lives. The authorities here have not suggested that Duncan or his friends were involved in any criminal behavior. But the appeal of the hip-hop environment is strong, and a lot of good kids are striving to conform to images established by clowns like 50 Cent and Snoop Dogg.

The members of Graveside wanted badly to make it as rappers. Said one police officer, ''They probably didn't even know they were playing with fire.''

The Rev. Eugene Rivers, who has been fighting for years to reduce youth violence in Boston and elsewhere, was a neighbor of E. J. Duncan's. ''My son Malcolm knew E. J. well,'' he told me.

He described the murders as a massacre and said he has long been worried about the glorification of violence and antisocial behavior. ''Thug life,'' he said, ''is now being globalized,'' thanks to the powerful marketing influence of international corporations.

This problem is not limited to the black community. E. J. Duncan and his friends came from a variety of ethnic backgrounds. But it is primarily a black problem, and it is impossible to overstate its dimensions.

I understand that jobs are hard to come by for many people, and that many schools are substandard, and that racial discrimination is still widespread. But those are not good reasons for committing cultural suicide.

I'll paraphrase Sam Cooke: A change has got to come. Reasonable standards of behavior that include real respect for life, learning and the law have to be re-established in those segments of the black community where chaos now reigns.

This has to start with a commitment to protect and nurture all of the community's children. That may seem at the moment like a task worthy of Sisyphus because it will require overcoming what the Rev. Rivers has described as ''the sins of the fathers who have cursed their sons by their abandonment and neglect.''

Sisyphean or not, it's a job that has to be done.

December 22, 2005 in Media | Permalink


TrackBack URL for this entry:

Listed below are links to weblogs that reference Bob Herbert: Blowing the Whistle on Gansta Culture.:


I keep wondering when leaders of eminence will step forward and declare, unambiguously, that enough is enough

Didn't Tookie Wiliams do exactly that, and it doesn't appear to have got him any respect from Bob Herbert.

I've always thought Herbert was the profoundest bore.

Posted by: dsquared | Dec 22, 2005 11:42:07 PM

Tookie was a leader of eminence?

Tookie declared "enough was enough" when the law was dishing out the "enough" to him.

Earlier, when Tookie was free on to dish out "enough" on the community it was another matter.

Since I couldn't read Tookie's mind I accept his convenient reform as genuine. And I oppose the death penalty so life would have been OK with me.

But "eminence"?

Posted by: K | Dec 23, 2005 6:00:36 AM

He was the founder of the Crips. Who on earth might be considered a more eminent gangsta? Snoop Doggy Dogg? The Archbishop of Canterbury? The late Sir Yehudi Menhin? Throw me a bone here.

Posted by: dsquared | Dec 23, 2005 8:29:54 AM

Words are certainly flexible, sometimes sadly so. But eminence denotes honor or admiration from others for doing worthwhile work.

In your view Charles Manson, Adi Amin, and Timothy McViegh are eminent killers. So be it.

Next stop? Eminent child molesters?

Posted by: K | Dec 23, 2005 9:14:49 AM

Sorry D2, are you saying Tookie is a goodie or a baddie?

Whether you beleive capital punishment is just or not, I would say that anyone who founded a murderous bunch like the Crips definately falls into the latter category. Thus any form of art or culture that idolises his way of life could also be defined as bad or at least not something to encourage.

Black kids in the urban ghettos have a shit enough time as it is, surely they don't need yet more problems heaped on their benighted heads?

I seem to remember a campaign back when I was in my teens (sponsored by what is now called the pc left) called "positive images". If my memory doesn't fail me the intention was to depict persons of colour in positive roles in entertainment (responsible jobs, good parents etc).

If this is a good thing, then surely forms of entertainment that do the opposite (idolise blacks as drug dealers, pimps, hoes, and other forms of lowlife) must be bad.

Or are Herbert and I guilty of applying simple logic to a "complex" problem?


Posted by: The Remittance Man | Dec 23, 2005 9:15:23 AM